Pennsylvania Office
T: 267-705-4080
C: 412-603-0122
F: 484-344-5341
Download PA vCard
Blue Bell Executive Campus
470 Norristown Road, Suite 201
Blue Bell, Pennsylvania 19422
New Jersey Office
T: 609-375-2070
F: 888-761-8299
Download NJ vCard
100 Overlook Center, 2nd Floor
Princeton, New Jersey 08540

Laura Hill - Paralegal/Administrative Assistant
T: 267-705-4086
Stephanie Schwenk - Paralegal
T: 267-705-4091

Joyce S. Pickles joined the firm in 2016. Her practice primarily focuses on professional liability defense, providing representation for various insureds under professional liability policies such as lawyers, medical professionals, insurance brokers and more. She has also defended EPLI claims during her tenure at the firm.

Joyce began her practice in first-party property defense in Tampa, Florida, investigating sinkhole claims for Florida’s largest insurer. After a year of practice she moved back to her home state of Pennsylvania where she began exclusively practicing nursing home defense for several years. Her practice over the years has had her representing both carriers and insureds on the defense side. She specializes in coverage matters in both the first- and third-party liability context, but has also represented insureds in trucking, premises liability and auto litigation. Joyce has represented carriers for coverage litigation matters involving issues of bad faith, depreciation, mortgagees, carrier contribution, puffbacks, water losses, fires, dram shop, business interruption, reasonable and necessary repair costs, reservation of rights, interpleader and intervenor. She has conducted coverage investigations and assisted carriers in resolving cases in order to avoid litigation.

Before becoming a lawyer, Joyce worked as a reporter for the Greensburg Tribune-Review.

Professional Experience

Prior to joining Rebar Kelly, Joyce worked at three insurance law firms that each had a national and international focus. She represented both insureds and carriers on the defense side, with a primary focus on first- and third-party coverage.


The Florida State University College of Law, J.D. 2007; Indiana University of Pennsylvania, magna cum laude, B.A. in Journalism.

Joyce was the Vice President of the Mock Trial Team at FSU Law and a law clerk at the Florida Bar Association working on the Florida Bar Journal and the Florida Bar News.

Primary Practice Areas




Class Action





First Party


Third Party

Bar Memberships & Court Admissions
  • Pennsylvania
  • New Jersey
  • Florida
  • U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania
  • U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania
  • U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey
Professional Affiliations and Professional Organizations

Defense Research Institute, Trucking Law Committee

Representative Matters

Successfully argued before the Pennsylvania Superior Court regarding a default arbitration award

Achieved dismissal from litigation involving mortgageholder’s claim to coverage payment

Prevailed on summary judgment regarding replacement cost value owed before costs incurred

Prevailed at arbitration on a puffback case

Successfully briefed argument of no coverage before the Third Circuit in a dram shop case

Prevailed at summary judgment vs. another carrier on priority of payment in auto accident claim

Represented carrier in interpleader action involving multiple claimants

Representation of carriers in uninsured/underinsured motorist claim litigation

Personal Interests

Besides spending time with her husband and two-year-old son, Joyce enjoys devouring literature and taking in live music. She is a former collegiate athlete who loves cheering on the U.S. Women’s National Soccer Team.